Treadwear and Wet Grip Balance in High Aromatic Oil Extended SBR 1712

The utilization of emulsion styrene-butadiene rubber grade SBR 1712 in passenger car tire tread compounds introduces a process-dependent trade-off between wet grip and treadwear that cannot be resolved by oil loading alone. SBR 1712 is a cold-polymerized E-SBR extended with 37.5 phr of high aromatic oil, corresponding to 27.3 wt% total oil content on the oil-extended polymer, with a bound styrene content of 23.5% and a typical Mooney viscosity ML 1+4 at 100 °C in the range 46–56 MU when tested according to ISO 289-1:2019. In a tire tread formulation, the rubber hydrocarbon from SBR 1712 is frequently blended with high-cis butadiene rubber, carbon black N234, zinc oxide, stearic acid, sulfur, and a sulfenamide accelerator. Wet grip is conventionally correlated with the temperature- and frequency-dependent loss tangent tan δ measured at 0 °C under ISO 4664-1:2022, whereas rolling resistance is correlated with tan δ at 60 °C. Treadwear is measured as volume loss in a rotating cylindrical drum apparatus under ISO 4649:2021 method A. The high aromatic extender oil in SBR 1712 increases the low-temperature hysteresis that contributes to wet grip, but it also raises tan δ at 60 °C because aromatic ring interactions and free-volume effects broaden the glass transition. Sulfur crosslink density, adjusted by varying the sulfur-to-accelerator ratio between sulfur 1.6 phr and 2.0 phr with N-cyclohexyl-2-benzothiazole sulfenamide at 1.2 phr to 1.8 phr, sets the upper limit for abrasion resistance; excessive crosslink density reduces elongation at break and accelerates abrasive wear, while insufficient crosslink density lowers modulus and permits greater deformation under the abrasive load. On a 3.4 L tangential rotor internal mixer with a fill factor of 0.70, rotor speed 50 rpm, and ram pressure 0.5 MPa, the masterbatch discharge temperature is typically controlled between 145 °C and 155 °C to avoid premature sulfur reaction. Batch-to-batch variation in SBR 1712 Mooney viscosity from 46 MU to 56 MU can shift the compound Mooney viscosity by 8–12 MU in an ASTM D3185-06 evaluation recipe, requiring closed-loop adjustment of mixer rotor speed and extruder screw speed to maintain tread gauge. Published data for the specific comparison of high aromatic oil-extended SBR 1712 and TDAE-extended SBR in identical tread formulations is limited; however, multiple producer certificates of analysis show the oil extension range above. The following formulation gradient table summarizes representative property trends from a laboratory internal mixer using the ASTM D3185-06 curative system and carbon black N234; the values are indicative of the trade-off envelope and must be verified against current certificates of analysis before production use.

Formulation variableCompound ACompound BCompound CCompound D
SBR 1712 rubber hydrocarbon90 phr80 phr70 phr60 phr
High-cis BR10 phr20 phr30 phr40 phr
Carbon black N23480 phr80 phr80 phr80 phr
Added aromatic oil5 phr5 phr5 phr5 phr
Sulfur1.8 phr1.8 phr1.7 phr1.7 phr
CBS accelerator1.4 phr1.4 phr1.3 phr1.3 phr
tan δ at 0 °C0.300.270.240.21
tan δ at 60 °C0.220.200.180.17
DIN abrasion loss under ISO 4649125 mm³115 mm³108 mm³100 mm³
Shore A hardness65666768

When High-Cis BR Replaces a Fraction of SBR 1712 Rubber Hydrocarbon in a Wet-Grip-Optimized Tread Compound

Substitution of high-cis BR into an SBR 1712 tread compound is performed to reduce heat build-up and improve groove cracking resistance, but the phase separation between aromatic oil-swollen SBR domains and BR domains introduces a migration equilibrium that shifts with processing temperature. High-cis BR grades containing 96–98% cis-1,4 units and Mooney viscosity 45–55 MU under ISO 289-1:2019 are typically used at replacement levels up to 40 phr of rubber hydrocarbon. The aromatic extender oil migrates preferentially into the SBR phase because aromatic carbon in the oil interacts with phenyl groups of the styrene units; this uneven distribution broadens the tan δ peak and reduces the effective plasticization of the BR phase. In a laboratory internal mixer evaluation under ASTM D3185-06, replacing 30 phr of SBR 1712 rubber hydrocarbon with BR 9000 can reduce abrasion volume loss from approximately 125 mm³ to 108 mm³ under ISO 4649:2021, while tan δ at 0 °C decreases from approximately 0.30 to 0.24, and tan δ at 60 °C decreases from approximately 0.22 to 0.18. These changes are accompanied by an increase in Shore A hardness from 65 to 67 under ISO 48-4:2020 and a reduction in elongation at break from approximately 480% to 420% under ISO 37:2017. The processing penalty is a higher mixing torque in the masterbatch stage because BR has no extender oil and develops greater shear viscosity; on a 3.4 L tangential internal mixer, rotor speed must be increased from 50 rpm to 55 rpm or the fill factor reduced from 0.70 to 0.68 to maintain discharge temperature below 155 °C. Published data for this specific configuration is limited, and the exact magnitude of property shift depends on carbon black structure, BR catalyst residue, and sulfur crosslink density.

Silica-silane tread compounds based on SBR 1712 require a different mixing calendar than carbon black formulations because the pre-existing 37.5 phr aromatic oil lowers the initial viscosity and delays the silanization reaction between the bifunctional sulfur silane and the silanol groups of precipitated silica. In a 1.6 L intermeshing internal mixer with a fill factor of 0.72, silica at 80 phr, silane at 6.4 phr, SBR 1712 at 80 phr rubber hydrocarbon, and BR at 20 phr, the mixing sequence typically includes a dry silica addition stage at a starting temperature of 50 °C, a silanization hold at 145–155 °C for 90–120 s, and a final curative addition below 110 °C. The high aromatic oil acts as a viscosity depressant and can reduce the specific energy input during the silica incorporation phase by 0.05–0.10 kW·h/kg compared with an oil-free SBR grade, but the same oil can also interfere with the adsorption of silane onto silica surfaces if added too early. Silica dispersion is assessed by optical microscopy using ISO 11345:2020, with a target macro-dispersion rating of at least 85% for acceptable treadwear. The resulting compound typically shows tan δ at 0 °C between 0.30 and 0.35, tan δ at 60 °C between 0.10 and 0.14, and ISO 4649:2021 abrasion loss between 105 mm³ and 130 mm³, depending on silane concentration and silica surface area. Production-scale twin-screw continuous mixing of silica-filled SBR 1712 tread compounds has been reported in technical bulletins; a co-rotating twin-screw extruder with L/D 48:1, segmented kneading blocks, and barrel temperatures from 50 °C to 150 °C can achieve similar silica dispersion ratings at throughputs not achievable in batch mixers, but published data for this specific configuration is limited.

Does the Aromatic Oil Content of SBR 1712 Shift Tan δ at 0°C Independently of Filler Network Formation?

Dynamic mechanical analysis of SBR 1712 tread compounds under ISO 4664-1:2022 at 1 Hz and 0.1% strain shows that the tan δ peak associated with the segmental relaxation of the oil-swollen SBR phase is broadened and shifted relative to a dry E-SBR with the same bound styrene content. The high aromatic oil contributes a higher glass transition temperature than a paraffinic or naphthenic extender oil, which keeps the low-temperature shoulder of the tan δ curve elevated near 0 °C and improves wet grip; however, the same aromaticity increases tan δ at 60 °C because the oil participates in sub-ambient relaxations that extend into the running temperature range of a tire. In a carbon black-filled compound, the filler network contributes an additional dissipation mechanism through breakdown and reformation of carbon black aggregates. The storage modulus and loss modulus are measured together, and the tan δ values at 0 °C and 60 °C are not independent variables; a formulation change that increases low-temperature hysteresis generally increases high-temperature hysteresis unless selective polymer microstructure changes or filler coupling agents are used. The Williams-Landel-Ferry constants for SBR tread compounds are often taken as C1=8.86 and C2=101.6 K, but these are material-specific and must be recalculated from frequency sweeps between -60 °C and 80 °C using ISO 4664-1:2022 or ASTM D5992. Published data for the specific configuration of high aromatic oil-extended SBR 1712 with carbon black N234 is limited in open literature; the observed separation between 0 °C and 60 °C tan δ in a given tread compound is typically less than 0.10, which limits the ability to satisfy both wet grip and rolling resistance targets without filler or polymer modifications.

During continuous hot-feed extrusion of SBR 1712 tread compounds, the oil extension lowers the apparent viscosity but increases the sensitivity of die swell to screw speed and head pressure. A production-scale hot-feed single-screw extruder with L/D 16:1, barrel temperature 70 °C, screw speed 25 rpm, and head pressure 8–12 MPa can process a carbon black-filled SBR 1712 tread compound with a compound Mooney viscosity of 60–75 MU under ISO 289-1:2019. Die swell and shrinkage are influenced by the high aromatic oil content; if the oil distribution is not homogeneous due to insufficient mastication, the extruded tread profile can vary in gauge by 0.2–0.5 mm across a 250 mm wide profile. This variation is detected by a laser profile scanner and corrected by closed-loop screw speed adjustment, but the correction window is limited to approximately ±2 rpm before shear heating raises the compound temperature above 115 °C and risks scorch. Moisture absorption in SBR 1712 is low but not negligible; if the polymer is stored at relative humidity above 60%, pre-drying at 60 °C for 2 h in a desiccant dryer is required to prevent porosity in the extrudate. Incompatibility with peroxide curing is an operational boundary: the aromatic oil in SBR 1712 consumes peroxide-derived radicals through hydrogen abstraction, reducing crosslink efficiency, and sulfur vulcanization under ASTM D3185-06 is therefore the default cure system. The compound should not be exposed to open steam curing for extended periods beyond the optimum cure time determined by ISO 6502:2016, because the aromatic oil can migrate to the surface and form a tacky residue that affects downstream tire building adhesion.

Cure Kinetic Limits in Sulfur-Accelerated SBR 1712 Compounds

Vulcanization kinetics of SBR 1712 tread compounds are measured with a moving die rheometer under ISO 6502:2016 at 160 °C, 0.5° arc, and 1.67 Hz. The sulfur-accelerated cure system with sulfur at 1.6–2.0 phr and CBS at 1.2–1.8 phr produces a scorch time ts2 between 2.5 min and 4.5 min and a torque increase MH minus ML between 8 dN·m and 14 dN·m depending on carbon black loading. The cure rate index, calculated as 100/(t90-ts2), typically falls between 15 min⁻¹ and 25 min⁻¹ for this grade. The aromatic oil modifies the effective crosslink density by diluting the polymer phase; equilibrium swelling in toluene under ISO 1817:2022 provides an indirect crosslink density that is lower than a dry SBR compound at the same sulfur level. The relationship between crosslink density and tan δ at 0 °C is non-linear; increasing crosslink density initially raises the modulus and reduces abrasion loss, but beyond a critical crosslink density, the reduction in elongation at break under ISO 37:2017 leads to a faster rate of abrasive wear under ISO 4649:2021. On a production-scale curing press, the difference between optimum cure time and overcure at 160 °C is narrow; a 2 min overcure can increase Shore A hardness by 1–2 units and reduce elongation at break by 30–50%, which is an operational boundary for thick tread sections in winter tires. Amine-based additives, including condensation products of acetone and diphenylamine, can shorten scorch time and should not be combined with SBR 1712 tread compounds unless the cure system is reoptimized using rheometer data under ISO 6502:2016.

Regulatory or test requirementStandard or regulationNumerical limit or method parameter
Evaluation of SBR 1712 in carbon black-filled compoundASTM D3185-06Curative system and mixing procedure for oil-extended SBR
Mooney viscosity of raw SBR 1712ISO 289-1:2019ML 1+4 at 100 °C: 46–56 MU
Abrasion resistance of vulcanized tread compoundISO 4649:2021Method A, rotating cylindrical drum, volume loss 100–130 mm³ depending on formulation
Dynamic hysteresis for wet grip and rolling resistanceISO 4664-1:2022tan δ at 0 °C and 60 °C, 1 Hz, 0.1% strain
Cure characteristicsISO 6502:2016MDR at 160 °C, 0.5° arc
Tensile stress-strain propertiesISO 37:2017Type 2 dumbbell, 500 mm/min
HardnessISO 48-4:2020Shore A
PAH limits for extender oils in tyresEU REACH Annex XVII Entry 50BaP 1 mg/kg; sum of eight PAH 10 mg/kg

Regulatory compliance for high aromatic oil-extended SBR 1712 in European tire applications is governed by REACH Annex XVII Entry 50, which restricts the placing on the market of extender oils containing more than 1 mg/kg benzo(a)pyrene or more than 10 mg/kg of the sum of eight specified polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons. Producers of SBR 1712 for EU markets therefore supply low-PAH aromatic extender oils or TDAE alternatives under the same grade designation; the rubber hydrocarbon content and Mooney viscosity window remain controlled under ISO 289-1:2019, but the aromatic carbon content and glass transition contribution of the oil differ slightly. In applications where the tire tread must meet EU tyre label wet grip class B or higher under Regulation (EU) 2020/740, the wet grip index is measured on a wet asphalt surface with a standardized reference tire, not predicted solely from tan δ at 0 °C. The correlation between laboratory dynamic data and vehicle wet grip is influenced by tire construction and road surface roughness; tan δ at 0 °C is an indicator rather than a direct compliance value. Treadwear performance under ISO 4649:2021 laboratory abrasion testing does not directly translate to road treadwear under fleet conditions, and published data for this specific configuration is limited. The operational boundary for a compounder is therefore narrow: the SBR 1712 grade can deliver balanced wet grip and treadwear only if Mooney viscosity, extender oil aromaticity, carbon black or silica dispersion, and sulfur crosslink density are simultaneously controlled within the ranges specified above.

Related Articles